Honestly Speaking: The Edit
Issue 09

Going Home Without Going Backward

NOVEMBER 2026 / FAMILY, CHANGE & CONNECTION

Geinel Johnson, LMFT | Issue 09 · November 2026 | 8 min read
Black woman in a green blazer

You ever notice how you can be a whole grown adult, paying bills, making decisions, running a household, maybe even running a business, and somehow one Thanksgiving dinner can have you feeling like you’re 17 again?

You’ve spent years figuring out who you are. You’ve learned to speak up for yourself, stopped explaining every decision, and gotten comfortable saying no.

Then you walk into your family’s house.

Somebody asks why you still don’t have a man. Somebody else has something to say about your weight, your career, or how you just let your kids do anything. And before you’ve even fixed your plate, you’re defending a decision you made six months ago.

Or maybe nobody says anything particularly offensive. You just notice yourself doing what you’ve always done. Keeping everybody happy. Refilling everybody’s drinks before anyone asks, and somehow you’re still the only one who knows where the foil is. Laughing off comments that actually bother you. Agreeing to things you don’t want to do because you already know how the conversation will go if you say no.

You told yourself in the car, Not this year. By the time the rolls came out, it was this year.

And afterward, you’re sitting in that same car wondering, Why do I keep doing that? I thought I was past this.

Editorial family photograph
Section 01

The People Who Knew You First

In family therapy, there's something called differentiation of self. Fancy name, simple idea: Can you be around your family without forgetting you're a grown-ass adult who gets to make her own decisions?

Because apparently, Thanksgiving is the final exam.

You can manage a whole team at work, negotiate contracts, handle emergencies, and make decisions all day long. But let your mama say, “You ain't leaving already, are you?” and suddenly you're explaining your whereabouts like you still have a curfew.

And the wild part? Sometimes nobody even has to say anything.

You see the dishes piling up, and you're already in the kitchen. Your brother has been sitting on that couch since the Cowboys game started, but somehow you're the one washing everybody's plates.

Now, maybe you genuinely enjoy helping. Nothing wrong with that. But here's what I'd ask you if we were sitting across from each other:

Are you doing it because you want to, or because you already know what happens when you don't?

That's the part worth paying attention to.

Families have a way of assigning us roles early. The responsible one. The peacemaker. The one who never needs anything. And after enough years, you can get so good at playing your part that you don't even wait for somebody to ask.

You just clock in.

And listen, your family might genuinely appreciate everything you do. But appreciation doesn't automatically mean the arrangement still works for you.

So before you spend another holiday irritated that everybody expects you to do the same old thing, consider this:

Have you actually given yourself permission to do something different, or are you still waiting for your family to give it to you?

Because differentiation isn't about loving your family less. It's about being able to love them without automatically becoming whoever they expect you to be.

And sometimes that starts before you even pull into the driveway.

Cinematic family moment
Section 02

Deciding What Works for You This Year

Now, before you even get to Thanksgiving, I have a question.

Do you actually want to go?

And don't give me the answer you've been giving your mama since September. I'm asking what you want.

Because some of y'all have already agreed to cook three dishes, pick somebody up from the airport, and arrive early to help set up. Meanwhile, you haven't even decided whether you want to be there.

Girl. How did you get a whole job assignment for a holiday you haven't RSVP'd to?

Maybe you do want to go. You love your family, you want to see everybody, and you're looking forward to that sweet potato pie. You just don't want to spend eight hours there.

Maybe you'd rather make an appearance, eat, laugh with your cousins, and be home in time to watch a movie in your pajamas.

Or maybe you're not going at all this year.

And here's where it gets complicated.

Because in some families, “I'm not coming” is apparently interpreted as “I no longer love any of you.”

Now your mama's disappointed. Your auntie wants an explanation. Somebody's bringing up how many holidays Grandma has left.

And before you know it, you're negotiating a decision you already made.

Here's what I want you to think about: Are you reconsidering because you've genuinely changed your mind, or because somebody is uncomfortable with your answer?

Those are two different things.

This is where a lot of us get stuck. Not on the decision, but on sitting with somebody being disappointed in it. Especially if you grew up believing keeping everybody happy was your job.

But being considerate doesn't mean every family expectation automatically becomes your responsibility.

You can love your family and still make other plans.

You can show up for two hours instead of eight.

And you can say, “I'm doing something different this year, but I'd love to see you next weekend.”

No courtroom defense necessary.

Now, I'm not telling you to skip Thanksgiving just because somebody gets on your nerves. Every family has its personalities, and sometimes maintaining relationships means making room for people who don't do everything the way we would.

But there's a difference between making a thoughtful compromise and repeatedly abandoning what you want because you don't want anybody upset with you.

The goal isn't to get everybody to agree with your decision. It's to make one you can stand behind.

And once you get to that dinner table? Well, that's when we find out how much you've been practicing.

Editorial portrait
“
You can love the people who knew the old you without handing them the responsibility of deciding who you get to be now.
Section 03

When Somebody Has Something to Say

You've made your plans. You've decided how long you're staying. You've even rehearsed how you're going to handle that one relative who always has a little something to say.

And then, right on schedule:

“You sure you need another plate?”

“So when are you finally getting married?”

“You used to be so much more fun before you started going to therapy.”

There it is. Right between the sweet potatoes and the cranberry sauce nobody touched.

Your face gets hot. Your chest tightens. You've got six responses ready, and four of them might get you removed from the family group chat.

But before you give Auntie the speech you've been saving since Easter, I want you to notice something.

What happens in your body right before you become the version of yourself you promised you weren't going to be?

In therapy, we sometimes talk about the window of tolerance. It's the range where you can experience strong feelings and still think clearly enough to choose your response. When you're pushed outside that range, you might snap, shut down, or agree just to make the moment end.

So if your shoulders are up by your ears and you're mentally preparing a closing argument, that's probably not the moment to have a productive conversation.

Put your feet on the floor. Take a slow breath. Go get some water. Give yourself a minute.

And then decide whether this is even a conversation you want to have.

Because some of us are so used to defending ourselves that we forget we can simply decline the invitation to argue.

You can say:

“I'm not discussing my relationship today.”

Or redirect:

“When there's news, you'll be the first to know. Now pass the mac and cheese.”

And if somebody keeps pushing?

“I've already answered that, and I'm not going to keep discussing it.”

You don't need to come up with a new explanation every time they ask. Repeating your answer calmly can be more effective than trying to convince somebody who isn't interested in understanding.

Now, if your auntie is genuinely curious and you actually want to talk, that's different. Every uncomfortable question isn't an attack.

But if you've answered, redirected, and made yourself clear, you can end the conversation.

Here's the question I'd want you to ask yourself:

Am I having this conversation because I want to, or because I still feel like I owe everybody an explanation?

And listen, you might still get irritated. You might even say something you wish you'd said differently.

That's human.

The goal isn't to become so emotionally regulated that nothing your family says ever bothers you.

The goal is to recognize when you're getting pulled into an old pattern before you spend the entire drive home rehearsing what you should've said.

Although, knowing some of our families, you might still have a few thoughts on that drive.

Quiet reflection
Section 04

When the Guilt Follows You Home

So you did it.

You said no. You left when you planned to. You didn't take the bait when somebody made that comment.

Look at you!

And then you get home, put on your pajamas, settle into the couch, and start thinking.

Was I rude?

Should I have stayed longer?

Maybe I should text my mama.

Now you're considering apologizing for leaving Thanksgiving at the time you told everybody you were leaving Thanksgiving.

Ma'am. What are we apologizing for?

Sometimes guilt is useful. If you were unnecessarily cruel, broke a promise, or treated somebody badly, that feeling might be telling you there's something to repair.

But sometimes guilt shows up because you did something your family isn't used to you doing.

And those are two very different situations.

In family systems therapy, there's a concept called homeostasis. Basically, families develop familiar ways of operating, and when one person changes, everybody has to adjust.

Think about it. If you've always been the one who says yes, your no might surprise people. If you've always handled everything, somebody might be annoyed when they suddenly have to figure it out themselves.

And if you've spent years making sure nobody gets upset with you, their disappointment might feel like an emergency.

But here's what I want you to ask yourself:

Did I actually hurt somebody, or did somebody simply not get what they wanted from me?

Because if you were hurtful, you can own that.

“I didn't like how I spoke to you earlier, and I'm sorry for that. But I'm still not discussing my relationship.”

An apology for your delivery doesn't require you to take back your decision.

And if you weren't hurtful? Maybe there's nothing to fix.

Maybe your mother is disappointed. Maybe your auntie thinks you've changed. Maybe somebody has an opinion about how long you stayed.

They can have those feelings.

And you can still have made a reasonable decision.

Here's where I want to challenge you a little.

If the only way you know you've made the right decision is that everybody else is happy with it, whose life are you actually living?

That's the work.

Not just learning how to say no, but learning how to sit with the discomfort that sometimes follows.

And before you go to bed replaying the whole day, try something different. Think of one moment when you responded in a way your younger self might not have.

Maybe you spoke up. Maybe you didn't explain yourself. Maybe you caught yourself getting defensive and changed course.

Give that moment some credit.

Because you don't need to have a perfect Thanksgiving to recognize that something about the way you're showing up is changing.

And maybe that's what going home without going backward really means.

Your family might still ask the same questions. Your auntie might still have an opinion. Your brother might still be sitting on that couch while everybody else cleans up.

But you don't have to keep playing your part exactly the same way.

You can love the people who knew the old you without handing them the responsibility of deciding who you get to be now.

Reflect & Practice

Try This | Before You Go

Finish this sentence:

“In my family, I'm usually the one who…”

Now think of one moment when that role tends to show up. Choose one sentence you can practice saying differently this year.

You don't have to change the whole family dynamic in one afternoon. Start with one response.

Geinel Johnson, LMFT

A Note From Geinel

Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday. The food, the games, the family, the laughter. I love all of it.

But let me tell you, the version of me that shows up for Thanksgiving today is not the same version from ten years ago.

Baby, I used to be doing the MOST.

Starting the group chat to figure out whose house we were going to. Asking who's bringing what. Picking people up, dropping people off, making sure everybody had a ride and nobody got left behind.

I was practically running a holiday transportation service. For free.

And now?

Tell me where we're going and what time we're eating. I'll be there.

Need a ride? If you're on my way, absolutely. If I have to drive 40 minutes in the opposite direction? Mmm. We might need to figure something else out.

And guess what? I still love Thanksgiving. I still love my family. I'm still showing up, eating good, laughing, and enjoying myself.

I'm just not doing the most anymore.

And sometimes people have to adjust to that. Sometimes I have to adjust to it, too.

Because when you've spent years being the person who makes things happen, doing less can feel strange, even when it's exactly what you need.

But here's what I've learned: I can love my family, enjoy our traditions, and be present without being responsible for everybody else's holiday experience.

And listen, everybody might not like the new arrangement. That's okay. Change is hard, especially when somebody else's change means you have to do something differently.

But listen… did you die?

No? Okay then. You'll be alright. 😂

With love,

Geinel

If family gatherings bring up feelings or experiences that are difficult to work through on your own, therapy can be a place to explore those patterns and practice responding differently.

The Honestly Speaking Journal offers education and reflection and is not a substitute for individualized mental health care.

About the Author

Geinel Johnson, LMFT

Geinel Johnson is a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist and the founder of Honestly Speaking Solutions, a boutique private practice serving adults and couples throughout California and Texas.

She specializes in helping high achieving Black professionals and couples navigate burnout, emotional exhaustion, relationship challenges, and the invisible weight that often comes with always holding it all together.

Known for blending clinical expertise with honest, culturally grounded conversations, Geinel created The Honestly Speaking Journal to help readers better understand themselves and create lives that feel as authentic as they are successful.

When she is not in session, she is usually exploring the Bay Area, planning her next trip, or spending a quiet night at home watching one of her favorite 90s Black love stories.

She believes healing begins the moment we stop performing who we think we have to be and start telling ourselves the truth.

Continue the Conversation

Honestly Speaking Solutions

info@honestlyspeakingsolutions.com

If something in this issue stayed with you, do not let it end here. Share it with someone who came to mind while you were reading. Sit with the questions that surfaced. Talk about it with someone you trust.

If you are ready to have these conversations in a space where you do not have to carry everything alone, I would be honored to walk alongside you.

Schedule a Consultation